7 Hershey Eateries Locals Swear By (That Aren’t at the Park)
If you’re looking to explore beyond the gates of Hersheypark, you’re in for a treat—literally. These local gems offer more than just great food; they serve up history, hospitality, and the kind of warmth that keeps people coming back again and again. As Milton Hershey once said, “Give them quality. That’s the best kind of advertising in the world.” These restaurants do exactly that.
Fenicci’s of Hershey
Attire: Casual
📍 Address: 102 W Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA 17033
📞 Phone: (717) 533-7159
🌐 Website: feniccis.com
In operation since 1935, Fenicci’s is an icon. Expect red sauce classics, family recipes passed down for generations, and the one-of-a-kind spaghetti pizza. It's the kind of place that might just know your name (and your order).
Tröegs Independent Brewing
Attire: Casual
📍 Address: 200 E Hersheypark Dr, Hershey, PA 17033
📞 Phone: (717) 534-1297
🌐 Website: troegs.com
Started by brothers John and Chris Trogner, Tröegs is both a beer lover’s paradise and a destination for scratch-made fare—like duck confit flatbreads and next-level beer cheese. A true local haunt with big flavor and bigger community vibes.
Piazza Sorrento
Attire: Casual
📍 Address: 16 Briarcrest Square, Hershey, PA 17033
📞 Phone: (717) 835-1919
🌐 Website: piazzasorrento.com
Authentic, cozy, and family-owned, Piazza Sorrento serves scratch-made Italian favorites with real heart. Loved by locals for its handmade pastas, signature sauces, and gluten-free options that don’t skimp on flavor.
The Hershey Pantry
Attire: Casual
📍 Address: 801 E Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA 17033
📞 Phone: (717) 533-7505
🌐 Website: hersheypantry.com
This cheerful cafe has been a go-to brunch spot since 1990. French toast, cinnamon rolls, and hearty omelets rule the morning. Pro tip: grab a seat on the screened-in porch if the weather’s nice.
What If…Of Hershey
Attire: Casual to Cocktail
📍 Address: 845 E Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA 17033
📞 Phone: (717) 533-5858
🌐 Website: whatifdining.com
Hidden beneath the Howard Johnson, this underground bistro brings surprising sophistication with candlelit ambiance and globally inspired dishes. A local’s pick for special occasions—or when you just want a little extra.
The Circular at The Hotel Hershey
Attire: Resort Casual
📍 Address: 100 Hotel Rd, Hershey, PA 17033
📞 Phone: (844) 330-1711
🌐 Website: thehotelhershey.com/dining/the-circular.php
A grand dining room with a view, The Circular is fine dining done the Hershey way. Seasonal menus, white tablecloths, and the legacy of Milton Hershey himself live on in every detail.
The Chocolate Avenue Grill
Attire: Casual
📍 Address: 114 W Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA 17033
📞 Phone: (717) 835-0888
🌐 Website: chocolateavenuegrill.com
Blending upscale flavors with a relaxed patio vibe, this local favorite is known for crab cakes, ahi tuna, and balsamic-glazed Brussels sprouts.
Hungry yet? These are the places locals point you to when you ask where to eat in Hershey—and now you’re in on the secret.